Skip to main content

Labor board sues Arizona over antiunion law


Employee Free Choice Act

Three other states may face NLRB suits

IF THE EMPLOYEE Free Choice Act ever became law (the legislation has been halted for now in the U.S. Congress), workers could form a union simply and quickly. All they would need is a majority of the proposed bargaining unit to sign cards. Or they could opt for a secret ballot election. However, governments in four states — all led by Republican governors and Republican-majority legislatures — have recently passed constitutional amendments to deny workers the first option, in effect heading off any future Free Choice law.

The National Labor Relations Board has cried foul and has filed suit against Arizona seeking to invalidate the state’s amendment. The NLRB is expected to file a similar suit against South Dakota soon, and may move against the amendments in South Carolina and Utah at a later date.

The NLRB says the state amendments conflict with current federal law which allows an employer to grant voluntary recognition of a collective bargaining agent after a majority of employees have signed authorization cards. The new state laws would deny employers that option, making secret ballot elections the only choice. The labor board further contends that the four states are in violation of the supremacy clause of the U.S. Constitution that says when state and federal laws conflict, federal laws prevail.

Organized labor has supported Employee Free Choice legislation to counter the tactics of employers who circumvent or violate current labor laws. Among those tactics are purposely delaying elections to weaken organizing campaigns, firing employees who are active in organizing, and coercing employees in one-on-one meetings into rejecting the union. Antiunion companies and their allies often argue, falsely, that the Employee Free Choice Act would deny workers the right to secret ballot elections — and they claim they are only interested in “protecting the rights” of employees.

Tags  LEAP Issues
Reporter  V50N2
Published on the Web: June 8, 2011

Latest News

  • Chuck Westphal was a retired member of Local 169, a representative in the Fight Back program and former president of the Michigan Tri-County Building Trades.

    Boilermaker and former State Building Trades President Chuck Westphal passes

    Read More

  • Two retired L-60 members receive a handmade quilt from the non-profit Quilts of Valor to thank them for their service during the Vietnam War. L. to r.: Rod Johnson, L-60’s John Williams and Jack Cooper, and Terry Johnson.

    Two L-60 veterans awarded Quilts of Valor for military service

    Read More

  • Local 627’s Shane “Kalai” Ferreira, who works for BAE Systems in Hawaii, offers reasons why a strong Jones Act is essential to the nation. L to r: BM-ST Jacob Evenson; Jesse Isleman, legislative aide of Sen. Brian Schatz (D-HI); Wesley Dale and Ferreira.

    Delegates advocate for local and national issues during LEAP

    Read More

  • Warren Fairley, IVP-Southeast, talks about the power in numbers when owners, contractors and Boilermakers collaborate.

    Southeast Area Tripartite homes in on ‘industrial evolution’

    Read More

  •  IR Cory Channon, far right, explains the Boilermakers’ role in CCUS. Left, Ahmad O. Al Khowaiter, Chief Technology Officer, Saudi Aramco; center, Artur Runge-Metzger, Director of Climate Strategy, Governance and Emissions from Non-trading Sectors, DG Climate Action of the European Commission.

    Union makes case for CCUS at Scotland conference

    Read More